Katie has always been a butterface. She just benefited from getting a lot of traction during prime instagram.
She was being reposted all over for you pages (fyp) left and right. As that all American girl. Posing in bikinis while riding 4 wheelers, and fishing. Middle America got hooked!
Men have a huge tendency to over value women and their looks. Because of less access and lust. While women have a tendency to under value men, because they have easier access to men.
She's everybody's girlfriend, but nobody's wife... A fuck and duck if you will.