MEGATHREAD! Plain Janes / Girl Next Door / Ordinary Women

EloiseNeg · Aug 3, 2024

Ordinary girls! Girls who don't particularly stand out, either in face/physique or the type of content they shoot i.e they make mostly vanilla porn. They don't necessarily have to be mediocre, they can be above average too. Basically the "girl next door" archetype. Obviously this will vary from person to person, but feel free to share girls who you think fit the bill. I'll start us off

Alex Blake - https://simpcityopen.com/threads/742/
Megan Sage - https://simpcityopen.com/threads/39498/
Lily Love - https://simpcityopen.com/threads/7327/
Judy Jolie - https://simpcityopen.com/threads/44982/
Jane Wilde - https://simpcityopen.com/threads/1621/
Catalina Ossa - https://simpcityopen.com/threads/80679/

Will post more if this thread gains tractions!

EloiseNeg · Aug 10, 2024

Their imperfections make them perfect!
7. Savannah Sixx - https://simpcityopen.com/threads/1540/

8. Natalie Monroe - https://simpcityopen.com/threads/528/

9. Alice March - https://simpcityopen.com/threads/26069/

10. Penelope Reed - https://simpcityopen.com/threads/36875/

11. Bailey Brooke - https://simpcityopen.com/threads/52690/

12. Kylie Quinn - https://simpcityopen.com/threads/13867/

Feel free to post women who you think fit the description!

lastperiod4 · Mar 4, 2025

Great thread! Wish more would jump in and add some more… These are my favorite kind of girls too.
A fav in this category would have to be Oakley Rae…
https://simpcityopen.com/threads/10090/

B7F09646-8539-4D2C-921D-33D2295AF0FD.th.jpg

D0C9CBEE-2AFB-4ED4-A702-450FF8947836.th.jpg

A86568E4-B04C-4508-87D9-5A4A72441EA8.th.jpg

EloiseNeg · Mar 4, 2025

Let me post a personal favorite of mine, Gianna Gem. Very cute, very pretty smile and a fat booty. This also might seem weird but she's the only girl I've ever noticed with substantial forearm hair and I kind of find that hot.

lastperiod4 · Mar 4, 2025

Damn she really does have some hairy arms!
You know who else was sorta cute and also had hairy arms….? Alyssa Milano

Bruno6 · Mar 4, 2025

One of my favorites

https://simpcityopen.com/threads/86209/
https://coomer.st/fansly/user/451976807713878016
edit: she's definitely not vanilla but she's got a somewhat average body type

ElmoV4 · Mar 4, 2025

My all time favourite Nadia Foxx

4021ff5e87d73bfc4a48d0cbbd0da66c39039f20b198162186e5bfa9746b1b18.jpg

4ec4e09fd3cd441a7dc793b0c5ce11da300a7c2662dcddd1cf436f666519c2dd519ca72c7648ab6e.md.jpg

a3e9e7df50d7114ab4b50a0ae3125bede3e66125cd5cf7baaf0ce73dcdcc40f334844a60a767b763.md.jpg

960x960_e6340e3f725a74ec6b6dc6c908b3caaa.md.jpg

EloiseNeg · Mar 13, 2025

Just realized Alex Coal is an excellent example for this thread. Apparently she even admits it herself.

branko6 · Aug 14, 2025

yasmin.forest
I really wish someone would make a content thread for her
Onlyfans
Instagram

branko6 · Aug 28, 2025

Finally I can make one

https://simpcityopen.com/threads/179613/

DarioMargin · Oct 18, 2025

Penny Flame
https://simpcityopen.com/threads/176939/

OttoLenz88 · Oct 28, 2025

Idk if she fits here...she might be too hot lol. But NorasPlaylist / thelovelynora does it for me. Like Emma Stone from superbad. Like you knew her in high school, but she had a glow up in college. I'll try to paint the picture.
She lived down the street in your neighborhood. You've known each other for a while, but she was always someone you overlooked because you knew her growing up. But it's the end of the summer, you're about to leave for university, and you end up making out at a party. Nothing more happens, but you go to take a look at her instagram the next day...

de0c40bcce511401f9e17f8f3ed21a244923bd8363b70db17749ddc29b4a44f0dae4fd507f7b30c3.jpg

Okay, she's definitely got it...how'd you overlook her until now?
You flirt over text for a bit. but it fizzles out as you both get into your freshman year. But you definitely keep tabs on her.

Summer comes and you're both back in your home town. You run into her at a party and catch up. Flirting resumes. You find yourself in the bathroom with her where she shows herself to you for the first time.

https://pixeldrain.com/l/wFv8sjU2#item=32

Then later that weekend, you text her. She just got out of the shower. With your impeccable 18 year old flirting skills you tell her to prove it.

c5b69304a457ca97cdeb9c20dac71b5fdc7727dc986477cd412fd07e79c9fda56d3ede5ba91dfe67.jpg

d52ca4f3f29ec5fd7cedb09474bc05221a28a27800552e33740bbb49d9ce6ba57eb2b7c8f151a719.jpg

With the nude barrier broken, you regularly get peeks at her body sent to your phone.

2682x4032_596ac104150b232df89e0e186b1ef0dad628e819646eab7a.jpg

2682x4032_7db8ee6a4f78e6116d886c01e3dc4f45927b8633c1d929c7.jpg

960x1444_b0531dea45d4d9e13d1077f6f311e77c8a206ee7e8657282.jpg

https://pixeldrain.com/l/zv7L4DuU#item=4

But the summer ends and you both end up back at school. You aren't dating but she is hot so you keep up with her. She still sends you nudes. Another year older, she grows up even more. More make up, new lingerie...she turns into a real baddie. But you will always think of her as that girl from down the street.